|

Page 9
Judge OKs FBI Keyboard Sniffing
The Justice Department can legally use a controversial electronic
surveillance technique in its prosecution of an alleged mobster.
In the first case of its kind, a federal judge in Newark, New Jersey
has ruled that evidence surreptitiously gathered by the FBI about Nicodemo
S. Scarfo's reputed loan shark operation can be presented in a trial later this
year.
U.S. District Judge Nicholas Politan said last week that it was perfectly
acceptable for FBI agents armed with a court order to sneak into Scarfo's
office, plant a keystroke sniffer in his PC and monitor its output.
Source: Wired, Jan 4, 2002
Opinion of Judge Politan in Matter of FBI Keyboard Sniffing
Dear Counsel:
This matter comes before the Court on Defendant Nicodemo S. Scarfo's (“Scarfo”)
pretrial motion for discovery and suppression of evidence. The Court heard oral
argument on July 30, 2001 and again on September 7, 2001. Co-defendant Frank
Paolercio (“Paolercio”) joined in the motion. The government thereafter moved to
invoke the Classified Information Procedures Act. For the following reasons, the
Defendants' motion for discovery is granted in part and denied in part, and the
motion to suppress evidence is denied.
BACKGROUND
This case presents an interesting issue of first impression dealing
with the ever-present tension between individual privacy and liberty rights and
law enforcement's use of new and advanced technology to vigorously investigate
criminal activity. It appears that no district court in the country has
addressed a similar issue. Of course, the matter takes on added importance in
light of recent events and potential national security implications.
Source:
http://lawlibrary.rutgers.edu/
December 26, 2001
FBI keyboard tap raises
cyber-age privacy issue
The courts may write new
privacy law before Congress can get around to it, as fast-emerging technology
provides law enforcement agencies with ever-powerful snooping tools. Experts say
a New Jersey case, in which the FBI intercepted every keystroke made on a
business computer, is likely to provoke the next big showdown.
At issue is how far
federal agents should be allowed to go in using high-tech tools to gain evidence
against suspects. Acting on a search warrant, FBI agents made surreptitious
entry to the offices of New Jersey businessman Nicodemo S. Scarfo and placed a
device in his computer keyboard, logging every keystroke. Agents took the
action, according to court records, to learn passwords to encryption software,
so they could read computer documents seized in an upcoming raid. Scarfo was
targeted as a suspect in gambling and loan-sharking operations.
Source: Virtual New York,
8 December 2000
FBI Database Monitors
Catholic Bishops and Pro-Life Groups
It has been rumored for
years, but dismissed as nutty conspiracy theory, that the federal government has
been assembling an extensive database on pro-life organizations under the
auspices of tracking potential criminals involved with “domestic terrorism.” The
Justice Department has admitted such a federal task force exists but has denied
it tracks innocent civilians or groups.
Then how to explain
newly obtained internal Justice Department documents that lay out justification
for “intrusive investigative activity” by the FBI, the Bureau of Alcohol,
Tobacco and Firearms, the U.S. Postal Inspection and U.S. Marshals services and
other federal law-enforcement agencies to compile dossiers on groups as
divergent as the National Conference of Catholic Bishops, the National Rifle
Association and the Women’s Coalition for Life?
Source: News World
Communications, Insight on the News Online, News Alter, July 17, 2000
Uncle Sam is Monitoring
Your Online Activities in a Big Way
While President Clinton has led an
effort to crack down on corporate snooping and impose new regulations on
business, privacy advocates say federal agencies still are collecting vast
amounts of data on visitors to taxpayer-sponsored Web sites.
Source: Scripps Howard News Service,
Capitol Hill Blue, June 24, 2000
Former Veep Mondale
opens FBI file, talks about excesses
When the young Minnesota attorney
general gave his speech at a civil rights rally in St. Paul, he didn't mean to
make an entry in a long and not very sexy chronicle of his life in politics. In
fact, he didn't know such a document existed.
The young politician was Walter
Mondale. The year was 1963. The diarist was an FBI agent on a routine assignment
to monitor yet another NAACP meeting. The journal was Mondale's FBI file.
Mondale said he
was horrified to learn how the FBI in the 1960s tailed, wiretapped and slandered
the Rev. Martin Luther King Jr., "attempting to destroy his movement and his
marriage."
The committee
found that the FBI had sought to destroy King by, among other things, bugging
hotel rooms in which he had extramarital sexual liaisons. Tapes and transcripts
were then circulated to journalists, politicians and other opinion leaders to
discredit King.
Source: Scripps Howard News Service,
June 4, 2000
FCC Grants FBI
Surveillance Standards Request
In a decision released on August 31,
the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) largely adopted technical standards
proposed by the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) that would re-design the
nation's telecommunications networks to facilitate electronic surveillance. The
ruling could result in a significant increase in government interception of
digital communications. Included is a requirement that cellular telephone
networks must provide police the ability to track the physical location of cell
phone users.
Source: Electronic Privacy Information
Center, 1 September 1999
Odd Coalition Would Curb Civil Forfeitures
In February, 1998, Federal agents confiscated the Red Carpet Motel in
Houston, Texas, even though the owners were not charged with any crimes.
The U.S. attorney in Houston announced that the motel owners "had "tacitly
approved" of drug activity by their guests by failing to implement police
security recommendations. One of those recommendations was to raise their room
rates."
Similar confiscations by federal agents have helped unite a bipartisan
coalition in Congress to pass the Civil Asset Forfeiture Reform Act, a bill,
that if passed, would make it harder for the federal government to seize private
property without filing criminal charges.
Source: The Washington Post (online), June 23, 1999
Clinton's IRS Gestapo
In a very real way, the IRS has been Clinton's secret police agency -- the
go-to guys when no other punishment will do.
Source: WorldNetDaily, March 19, 1999
Sleepers alarmed by helicopter-borne commandos
In the black of a peaceful winter night in the Beaver County countryside, the
first mean machines came chop-chop-chopping low and loud over Don and Phyllis
Wilfong's house at 3:27 a.m. yesterday, rattling the windows and obliterating
any hope of sleep."
Source: Post-Gazett.com, March 19, 1999
Questions loom over DNA databases
"Of the last 100 arrests for rape and sodomy (in New York City), 14 had
records (for sex offenses)," says New York City police Commissioner Howard Safir,
who has proposed testing everyone arrested. "But 75 had arrest records for all
kinds of smaller stuff. Think how many more could have been gotten (with a DNA
database of everyone arrested).'
But legal problems loom. The Constitution's Fourth Amendment protects against
unreasonable searches and seizures. Testing everyone arrested, says defense
lawyer and former Manhattan prosecutor Harlan Levy, is the sort of "blunderbuss
approach" the Constitution frowns on.
Source: USA Today
Reno urges study of broad DNA testing
Attorney General Janet Reno has asked a federal commission to study the
legality of taking DNA samples from everyone arrested instead of just the
convicted sex offenders and violent felons currently permitted by law.
Such widespread testing would hugely expand government's reach by placing the
genetic fingerprints of millions of Americans into state crime databases even if
they never were convicted of a crime.
Source: USA Today
FBI Proposes Electronic Survelance of
People
The FBI proposals would --
among other things -- enable law enforcement to determine the location of
individuals using cellular telephones. Also at issue is the surveillance of
"packet-mode" communications such as those that form the core of the Internet.
The comments were filed as part of the FCC's proceeding on implementation of the
controversial Communications Assistance for Law Enforcement Act (CALEA).
Source: Electronic Privacy
Information Center, December 17, 1998
Robots may soon be harder to shake off than a bloodhound
Big Brother may not only be watching you, he may be following you too.
Researchers in California have developed a robot called an Autonomous Observer
(AO) that could lead to surveillance systems that follow people wherever they
go.
Other systems can't follow moving objects that are trying to evade detection. If
an object disappears from view, the tracking system loses it. To overcome this,
computer scientist Jean-Claude Latombe at Stanford University has developed
small mobile robots that not only watch targets but also work out their
potential escape routes. The robots can then position themselves for an optimum
view.
Source: New Scientist, 17 October 1998
Inside view of Night Stalkers
The use of live fire in civilian areas during secret military training
exercises is not that uncommon, according to a former Night Stalker. Such
exercises are conducted in cities that give permission, and in others that have
not been consulted in advance.
Residents, who were not warned of the event, were reported to be extremely
frightened. A retirement home only a few hundred feet from the exercise,
reported many elderly people were fearful that the world was coming to an end
and were under beds crying. The sound of machine gun fire and explosives
continued for two hours.
Night Stalkers often are sent on missions directly into cities to see how far
they can get before someone calls 911. They monitor police frequencies and
listen for when a complaint comes in. When they are reported to local police
they abort the mission.
Source: WorldNetDaily
Stop terrifying small-town "invasions," Libertarians demand
of U.S. military
How would you like the U.S. military to 'invade' your town?
That's what happened -- complete with swooping attack helicopters, live
weapons fire, flashbang grenades, and buildings burnt to the ground -- without
warning in at least five towns in Texas and Louisiana over the past several
weeks.
Source: Libertarian Party Press Release
IRS Admits 'Sins' in Seizing Property
The Internal Revenue Service admitted on Friday [July 10, 1998]
that it improperly seized property from taxpayers in more than one in four cases
studied, including an attempt to force a dying man, his wife and two school-age
children from their home.
Source: Deseret News, Salt Lake City, Saturday, July 11, 1998,
pp. A1, A3.
No vacancy for drug dealers: Feds seize hotel
The complaint seeks forfeiture of a commercial enterprise -- the Red Carpet
Inn at 6868 Hornwood -- not financially tied to narcotics trafficking, a broader
interpretation of drug forfeiture laws usually used to confiscate property
purchased with drug money.
The hotel's owners, GWJ Enterprises, are accused of giving "tacit consent" to
illegal activity by failing to act to stop it after being notified by police and
city officials.
Source: HoustonChronicle.com, 2/17/1998
Clinton's 12 'National Emergencies'
President Clinton has all the authority he needs to place this country under
a dictatorship with the stroke of the pen.
He could do it at any time. Congress has given him the power. The laws are in
the statute books. And the courts have already refused to say "no."
Source: WorldNetDaily, January 26, 1999
Moving Toward a Police State
Executive orders ... national emergencies ... a domestic "commander-in-chief"
... the threat of terrorism and weapons of mass destruction. ....
An impeached president is leading America ever closer toward the reality of a
police state, and there's been hardly a peep from the civil liberties
establishment. In fact, those who dare address such issues are quickly denounced
as paranoid "extremists."
Source: WorldNetDaily, January 26, 1999
FBI Trys To Trick Richard Jewell
The decision by FBI agents to trick Richard Jewell into giving
up his right to a lawyer endangered the investigation of last year's bombing at
the Atlanta Olympic Games, the Justice Department said Monday
Source: NY Times
Additional stories about
Marine killing student
Sources: Houston Chronicle (online), 1997
Officials offer sympathy, but back border shooting
Senior federal and military officials Thursday offered their
sympathy to the family of a U.S. citizen shot by Marines on an anti-drug
operation near the border, but stood by their claim that the soldiers had no
choice but to kill the 18-year-old when he allegedly shot at them twice
while tending his family's goats.
Source: Houston Chronicle (online), May 22, 1997
Marine on anti-drug duty
shoots, kills student
A Marine on an anti-drug operation along the border near Big
Bend National Park shot and killed an 18-year-old high school student who
authorities said had opened fire.
Source: Houston Chronicle
(online), May 21, 1997
FBI Crime Laboratory
The US Inspector General issued a report that criticized the [FBI's
crime] laboratory, and the criticisms included the following points.
- Agents "working on such big cases as the World Trade Center and
Oklahoma City bombings produced flawed scientific reports and slanted
their findings to favor the prosecution."
- At least one instance is known where "an agency supervisor allowed
such evidence to be presented to the court, even when he know the
scientific evidence did not support the findings."
- "Even more disturbing, the FBI assigned someone who was known to
have produced flawed reports to the Oklahoma City bombing case."
- "When the people we entrust to enforce our laws start bending the
truth - particularly scientific evidence that few of us can afford to
test on our own - none of us is safe."
The author, Robert E. Precht, is director of the Office of Public Service
at the University of Michigan Law School.
Source: Deseret News (Utah), April 19, 1997
CIA Attempts To Assassinate Fidel Castro
The Associated Press reported that according to a CIA document
recently declassified, the CIA in the early 1960s tried to have Fidel Castro
assassinated. They contacted the Mafia and offered $150,000 for the "hit". At
least one other attempt by the CIA was made to murder Castro. Detailed knowledge
of these attempts was kept from the White House, although President Kennedy and
his brother Robert, the Attorney General, told the CIA to 'Do what ever it takes
to get rid of Castro.'
Source: The Salt Lake Tribune (Utah) July 2, 1997
|